Reviews of topical problems

Ultrahard nanomaterials: myths and reality

Institute for High Pressure Physics, Russian Academy of Sciences, Troitsk, Moscow, Russian Federation

The last 25 years has witnessed a wealth of publications on the creation of carbon materials whose compression bulk modulus and hardness are much higher than those of diamond. This review presents a critical analysis of these studies. Three groups of myths that have emerged lately are discussed. The first is related to the possibility of creating materials whose bulk moduli are significantly higher than those of diamond. The second group is devoted to 'experimentally measured' values of hardness, much higher than that of diamond. The third includes alleged 'theoretical' grounds for a several-fold (!) increase in the hardness of covalent substances due to the effects of quantum confinement. It is shown that materials whose elastic moduli significantly exceed those of diamond cannot in principle be produced under normal conditions. Issues surrounding the quantitative measurement of hardness are discussed; it is noted that the creation of obstacles to the movement of dislocations in nanomaterials may allow a 20—40% increase in the effective measured hardness of ultrahard materials. It is emphasized that alternative hypothetical approaches to increase hardness, for example, due to quantum confinement, actually have no physical grounds whatsoever. The highest mechanical characteristics of diamond are associated with reliably established physical laws, and any assertions regarding possible obtainment of materials whose elastic characteristics or hardness are several times greater than those of diamond may not be regarded as reliable to any extent or even science-based.

Fulltext pdf (1.1 MB)
Fulltext is also available at DOI: 10.3367/UFNe.2019.07.038635
Keywords: elastic moduli, hardness, carbon materials, nanostructures, quantum confinement
PACS: 62.20.−x, 62.20.Qp (all)
DOI: 10.3367/UFNe.2019.07.038635
Citation: Brazhkin V V "Ultrahard nanomaterials: myths and reality" Phys. Usp. 63 523–544 (2020)
BibTexBibNote ® (generic)BibNote ® (RIS)MedlineRefWorks

Received: 18th, April 2019, revised: 17th, July 2019, 26th, July 2019

Оригинал: Бражкин В В «Ультратвёрдые наноматериалы: мифы и реальность» УФН 190 561–584 (2020); DOI: 10.3367/UFNr.2019.07.038635

References (106) Cited by (9) Similar articles (20) ↓

  1. R.A. Andrievski “High-melting point compounds: new approaches and new results60 276–289 (2017)
  2. R.A. Andrievski, A.M. Glezer “Strength of nanostructures52 315 (2009)
  3. E.A. Ekimov, M.V. Kondrin “Vacancy-impurity centers in diamond: perspectives of synthesis and applications60 539–558 (2017)
  4. A.E. Galashev, O.R. Rakhmanova “Mechanical and thermal stability of graphene and graphene-based materials57 970–989 (2014)
  5. Yu.S. Nechaev “Metallic materials for the hydrogen energy industry and main gas pipelines: complex physical problems of aging, embrittlement, and failure51 681–697 (2008)
  6. A.D. Pogrebnjak, A.P. Shpak et alStructures and properties of hard and superhard nanocomposite coatings52 29–54 (2009)
  7. L.P. Babich “Relativistic runaway electron avalanche63 1188–1218 (2020)
  8. I.S. Aranson “Topological defects in active liquid crystals62 892–909 (2019)
  9. A.I. Savvatimskii, S.V. Onufriev “Investigation of the physical properties of carbon under high temperatures (experimental studies)63 1015–1036 (2020)
  10. P.B. Ivanov, E.V. Mikheeva et alInterferometric observations of supermassive black holes in the millimeter wave band62 423–449 (2019)
  11. A.A. Bukharaev, A.K. Zvezdin et alStraintronics: a new trend in micro- and nanoelectronics and material science61 1175–1212 (2018)
  12. D.S. Sanditov “Nature of Poisson's ratio of amorphous polymers and glasses and its relation to structure-sensitive properties63 327–341 (2020)
  13. A.D. Pogrebnyak, M.A. Lisovenko et alProtective coatings with nanoscale multilayer architecture: current state and main trends64 253–279 (2021)
  14. A.V. Khomenko, I.A. Lyashenko “Statistical theory of the boundary friction of atomically flat solid surfaces in the presence of a lubricant layer55 1008–1034 (2012)
  15. Yu.S. Nechaev “The distribution of carbon in steels54 465–471 (2011)
  16. L.V. Spivak “Synergy effects in the deformation response of thermodynamically open metal — hydrogen systems51 863–885 (2008)
  17. R.B. Morgunov “Spin micromechanics in the physics of plasticity47 125–147 (2004)
  18. R.A. Andrievski “Nanostructures under extremes57 945–958 (2014)
  19. M.Ya. Marov, I.I. Shevchenko “Exoplanets: nature and models63 837–871 (2020)
  20. G.V. Dedkov “Nanotribology: experimental facts and theoretical models43 541–572 (2000)

The list is formed automatically.

© 1918–2023 Uspekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk
Email: Editorial office contacts About the journal Terms and conditions