RSS feeds
РусскийEnglish
Issue 11, 2024
Volume year page
Issues Authors PACS Subscription For authors

Issues

 / 

2022

 / 

January

←  →

From the history of physics


Discovery of the relativistic Schrödinger equation

 a,  b,  c,  d
a Department of Applied Mathematics and Statistics, Stony Brook University, New York, New York, USA
b Department of Mathematics, Lamar University, 200 Lucas Building, P.O. Box 10047, Beaumont, TX, 77706, USA
c Landeshauptstadt München, Referat für Bildung und Sport, Seminar TMG Universität, Drygalski Allee 2, 81477, München, 11794-3600, Germany
d School of Mathematical and Statistical Sciences, Arizona State University, P.O. Box 871804, Tempe, AZ, 85287-1804, USA

We discuss the discovery of the relativistic wave equation for a spin-zero charged particle in the Coulomb field by Erwin Schrödinger (presumably during the Christmas holidays of 1925—1926). However, in this new approach, an essential discrepancy was found with the fine structure formula for energy levels already obtained by Sommerfeld in the framework of the 'old' quantum mechanics. As a result, Schrödinger had to withdraw the original 'relativistically framed' article, a draft of which has never been found, from a journal and start all over with his centennial article on the nonrelativistic stationary Schrödinger equation. Our goal here is to follow the original 'relativistic idea' from a modern mathematical viewpoint and elaborate on why Schrödinger did not publish it. We hope that this consideration will encourage readers to study quantum physics at one of the crucial moments of its creation.

Fulltext pdf (885 KB)
Fulltext is also available at DOI: 10.3367/UFNe.2021.06.039000
Keywords: Schrödinger equation, Klein—Fock—Gordon equation, Dirac equation, hydrogen atom, Sommerfeld fine structure formula, Wentzel—Kramers—Brillouin (WKB) approximation, Laplace transform, Nikiforov—Uvarov method
PACS: 01.65.+g, 03.65.−w (all)
DOI: 10.3367/UFNe.2021.06.039000
URL: https://ufn.ru/en/articles/2022/1/e/
000788597000005
2-s2.0-85128558753
2022PhyU...65...90B
Citation: Barley K, Vega-Guzmán J, Ruffing A, Suslov S K "Discovery of the relativistic Schrödinger equation" Phys. Usp. 65 90–103 (2022)
BibTexBibNote ® (generic)BibNote ® (RIS)MedlineRefWorks

Received: 23rd, January 2021, revised: 21st, June 2021, 30th, June 2021

Оригинал: Барли К, Вега-Гузман Х, Руффин А, Суслов С К «Открытие релятивистского уравнения Шрёдингера» УФН 192 100–114 (2022); DOI: 10.3367/UFNr.2021.06.039000

E. Shrödinger is author of Physics-Uspekhi

References (70) ↓ Cited by (4) Similar articles (20)

  1. Bloch F "Heisenberg and the early days of quantum mechanics" Phys. Today 29 (12) 23 (1976)
  2. Blokhintsev D I "Klassicheskaya statisticheskaya fizika i kvantovaya mekhanika" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 122 745 (1977); Blokhintsev D I "Classical statistical physics and quantum mechanics" Sov. Phys. Usp. 20 683 (1977)
  3. Dirak P A M "Relyativistskoe volnovoe uravnenie elektrona" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 128 681 (1979); Dirac P A M "The relativistic electron wave equation" Sov. Phys. Usp. 22 648 (1979)
  4. Einstein A Letters On Wave Mechanics: Correspondence With H.A. Lorentz, Max Planck, And Erwin Schrödinger (Ed. K. Przibram) (New York: Philosophical Library, 1967); Einstein A Letters On Wave Mechanics: Correspondence With H.A. Lorentz, Max Planck, And Erwin Schrödinger (Ed. K. Przibram) (New York: Open Road Integrated Media, 2011)
  5. El’yashevich M A "Ot vozniknoveniya kvantovykh predstavlenii do stanovleniya kvantovoi mekhaniki" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 122 673 (1977); El’yashevich M A "From the origin of quantum concepts to the establishment of quantum mechanics" Sov. Phys. Usp. 20 656 (1977)
  6. Joas C, Lehner C "The classical roots of wave mechanics: Schrödinger’s transformations of the optical-mechanical analogy" Studies History Philos. Sci. B 40 (4) 338 (2009)
  7. Kragh H "Erwin Schrödinger and the wave equation: the crucial phase" Centaurus 26 (2) 154 (1982)
  8. Mehra J "The birth of quantum mechanics" Werner Heisenberg Memorial Lecture Delivered at the CERN Colloquium on 30 March 1976 (CERN 76-10) (Genève: CERN, 1976); reprinted in, Mehra J "Birth of quantum mechanics" The Golden Age Of Theoretical Physics Vol. 2 (Singapore: World Scientific, 2001) p. 639; Per. na russk. yaz. M.B. Voloshina, Mekhra Dzh "Rozhdenie kvantovoi mekhaniki" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 122 719 (1977)
  9. Mehra J "Erwin Schrödinger and the rise of wave mechanics. II. The creation of wave mechanics" The Golden Age Of Theoretical Physics Vol. 2 (Singapore: World Scientific, 2001) p. 761
  10. Mehra J The Golden Age Of Theoretical Physics (Boxed Set Of 2 Volumes) (Singapore: World Scientific, 2001)
  11. Mehra J, Rechenberg H The Historical Development Of Quantum Theory. Vol. 5. Erwin Schrödinger And The Rise Of Wave Mechanics. Pt. 2. The Creation Of Wave Mechanics; Early Response And Applications 1925-1926 1st ed. (New York: Springer, 1987)
  12. Milant’ev V P "Sozdanie teorii Bora i ee razvitie (k 90-letiyu borovskoi teorii atoma)" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 174 209 (2004); Milant’ev V P "Creation and development of Bohr’s theory (on the 90th anniversary of the Bohr theory of the atom)" Phys. Usp. 47 197 (2004)
  13. Miller A I "Erotica, aesthetics and Schrödinger’s wave equation" It Must Be Beautiful: Great Equations Of Modern Science (Ed. G Farmelo) (London: Granta Publ., 2002) p. 110
  14. Renn J Erwin Schrödinger — 50 Years After (EMS ESI Lectures in Mathematics and Physics) Vol. 9 (Eds W L Reiter, J Yngvason) (Zürich: European Mathematical Society Publ. House, 2013) p. 9
  15. Smorodinskii Ya A, Romanovskaya T B "Lui de Broil’ (1892-1987)" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 156 753 (1988); Smorodinskii Ya A, Romanovskaya T B "Louis de Broglie (1892-1987)" Sov. Phys. Usp. 31 1080 (1988)
  16. van der Waerden B L (Ed.) Sources Of Quantum Mechanics (Classics of Science) Vol. 5 (New York: Dover Publ., 1968)
  17. Wessels L "Schrödinger’s route to wave mechanics" Studies History Philos. Sci. A 10 (4) 311 (1979)
  18. Cassidy D C Uncertainty: The Life And Science Of Werner Heisenberg (New York: W.H. Freeman and Company, 1991)
  19. Cassidy D C Beyond Uncertainty: Heisenberg, Quantum Physics, And The Bomb (New York: Bellevue Literary Press, 2009)
  20. Gribbin J Erwin Schrodinger And The Quantum Revolution 1st ed. (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons, 2012)
  21. Moore W J Schrödinger: Life And Thought (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1989)
  22. Farmelo G The Strangest Man: The Hidden Life Of Paul Dirac, Mystic Of The Atom (New York: Basic Books, 2009)
  23. Kapitsa P L Eksperiment, Teoriya, Praktika: Stat’i, Vystupleniya (M.: Nauka, 1974) p. 201, 202; Per. na angl. yaz., Kapitza P L Experiment, Theory, Practice: Articles And Addresses (Dordrecht: Reidel, 1980) p. 318, 319
  24. Mehra J "The discovery of electron spin" The Golden Age Of Theoretical Physics Vol. 1 (Singapore: World Scientific, 2001) p. 585
  25. Schrödinger E Ann. Physik 79 (6) 489 (1926); Per. na angl. yaz., Schrödinger E "Quantisation as a problem of proper values. Pt. I" Collected Papers On Wave Mechanics (New York: AMS Chelsea Publ., 2010) p. 1-12; Per. na russk. yaz., Shredinger E "Kvantovanie kak zadacha o sobstvennykh znacheniyakh. Pervoe soobshchenie" Izbrannye Trudy Po Kvantovoi Mekhanike. Osnovopolagayushchie Raboty Po Volnovoi Mekhanike 1926-1927 Gg. (M.: Nauka, 1976) p. 9-20
  26. Schrödinger E "An undulatory theory of the mechanics of atoms and molecules" Phys. Rev. II 28 (6) 1049 (1926); Per. na russk. yaz., Shredinger E "Volnovaya teoriya mekhaniki atomov i molekul" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 7 (3) 176 (1927)
  27. Dirac P A M "The evolution of the physicist’s picture of nature" Sci. Am. 208 (5) 45 (1963)
  28. Dirac P A M "My life as a physicist" Unity Of The Fundamental Interactions (Ed. A Zichichi) (New York: Plenum Press, 1983) p. 740-741
  29. Fock V "Zur Schrödingerschen Wellenmechanik" Z. Physik 38 (3) 242 (1926), received June 11, published July 28; reprinted, Fock V A Selected Works: Quantum Mechanics And Quantum Field Theory (Eds L D Faddeev, L A Khalfin, I V Komarov) (Boca Raton, Fl.: Chapman and Hill. CRC Press, 2004) p. 11-20
  30. Fock V "Über die invariante Form der Wellen- und der Bewegungsgleichungen für einen geladenen Massenpunkt" Z. Physik 39 (2-3) 226 (1926), received July 30, published October 2; reprinted, Fock V A Selected Works: Quantum Mechanics And Quantum Field Theory (Eds L D Faddeev, L A Khalfin, I V Komarov) (Boca Raton, Fl.: Chapman and Hill. CRC Press (2004) p. 21-28; Per. na russk. yaz. s nem., Fok V A "Ob invariantnoi forme volnovykh uravnenii i uravnenii dvizheniya zaryazhennoi tochechnoi massy" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 180 874 (2010); Fock V A "On the invariant form of the wave and motion equations for a charged point mass" Phys. Usp. 53 839 (2010)
  31. Okun’ L B "V.A. Fok i kalibrovochnaya simmetriya" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 180 871 (2010); Okun L B "V.A. Fock and gauge invariance" Phys. Usp. 53 835 (2010)
  32. Nikiforov A F, Uvarov V B Spetsial’nye Funktsii Matematicheskoi Fiziki 2-e izd. (M.: Nauka, 1984); Per. na angl. yaz., Nikiforov A F, Uvarov V B Special Functions Of Mathematical Physics: A Unified Introduction With Applications ((Boston, MA: Birkhäuser, 1988)
  33. Davydov A S Kvantovaya Mekhanika 2-e izd. (M.: Nauka, 1973); Per. na angl. yaz., Davydov A S Quantum Mechanics (Intern. Ser. of Monographs in Natural Philosophy) Vol. 1 (Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1965)
  34. Dirac P A M "The quantum theory of the electron" Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 117 (778) 610 (1928)
  35. Schiff L I Quantum Mechanics 3rd ed. (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1968); Per. na russk. yaz. 1-go izd., Shiff L Kvantovaya Mekhanika (M.: IL, 1959)
  36. Varshalovich D A, Moskalev A N, Khersonskii V K Kvantovaya Teoriya Uglovogo Momenta (M.: Nauka, 1975); Per. na angl. yaz., Varshalovich D A, Moskalev A N, Khersonskii V K Quantum Theory Of Angular Momentum (Singapore: World Scientific, 1988)
  37. Landau L D, Lifshits E M Kvantovaya Mekhanika. Nerelyativistskaya Teoriya 4-e izd. (M.: Nauka, 1974); Per. na angl. yaz., Landau L D, Lifshitz E M Quantum Mechanics: Non-Relativistic Theory 3rd ed. (Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1977); Per. na angl. yaz., Landau L D, Lifshitz E M Quantum Mechanics: Non-Relativistic Theory Revised and enlarged ed. (Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1998)
  38. Schlesinger L Einführung In Die Theorie Der Differentialgleichungen Mit Einer Unabhüngigen Variabeln, Summlung Schubert, No. XIII (Leipzig: G.J. Göschenshe Verlagshandlung, 1900)
  39. Suslov S K, Vega-Guzmán J M, Barley K "An introduction to special functions with some applications to quantum mechanics" Orthogonal Polynomials: 2nd AIMS-Volkswagen Stiftung Workshop, Douala, Cameroon, 5-12 October, 2018 (Tutorials, Schools, and Workshops in the Mathematical Sciences) Vol. AIMSVSW (Eds M Foupouagnigni, W Koepf) (Dordrecht: Springer, 2020) p. 517
  40. Bethe H A, Salpeter E E Quantum Mechanics Of One- And Two- Electron Atoms (Berlin: Springer, 1957); reprinted, Bethe H A, Salpeter E E Quantum Mechanics Of One- And Two- Electron Atoms (New York: Dover Publ., 2008); Per. na russk. yaz., Bete G, Solpiter E Kvantovaya Mekhanika Atomov s Odnim i Dvumya Elektronami (M.: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo fiziko-matematicheskoi literatury, 1960)
  41. von Meyenne K Eine Entdeckung Von Ganz Außerordentlecher Tragweite: Schrödingers Briefwechsel Zur Wellenmechanik Und Zum Katzenparadoxon (Berlin: Springer, 2011)
  42. Courant R, Hilbert D Methoden Der Mathematischen Physik (Berlin: Springer, 1924); Per. na angl. yaz., Courant R, Hilbert D Methods Of Mathematical Physics Vol. 1 (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons, 1989); Per. na russk. yaz., Kurant R, Gil’bert D Metody Matematicheskoi Fiziki Vol. 1 (M.-L.: GTTI, 1945)
  43. Schrödinger E Ann. Physik 79 (6) 489 (1926); Per. na angl. yaz., Schrödinger E "Quantisation as a problem of proper values (Pt. II)" Collected Papers On Wave Mechanics (New York: AMS Chelsea Publ., 2010) p. 13-40; Per. na russk. yaz., Shredinger E "Kvantovanie kak zadacha o sobstvennykh znacheniyakh. Vtoroe soobshchenie" Izbrannye Trudy Po Kvantovoi Mekhanike. Osnovopolagayushchie Raboty Po Volnovoi Mekhanike 1926-1927 Gg. (M.: Nauka, 1976) p. 21-50
  44. Sommerfeld A Atombau Und Spektrallinien Vol. 1 2nd ed. (Braunschweig: Friedrich Vieweg and Sohn, 1951); Per. na russk. yaz., Zommerfel’d A Stroenie Atoma i Spektry Vol. 1 (M.: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo tekhniko-teoreticheskoi literatury, 1956)
  45. de Broglie L "Sur la fréquence propre de l’électron" Comptes Rendus 180 498 (1925); Per. na russk. yaz., de Broil’ L De Broil’ L Izbrannye Nauchnye Trudy. T. 1. Stanovlenie Kvantovoi Fiziki: Raboty 1921-1934 Godov (M.: Logos, 2010) p. 203
  46. Kryuchkov S I, Lanfear N A, Suslov S K "The role of the Pauli-Lubański vector for the Dirac, Weyl, Proca, Maxwell and Fierz-Pauli equations" Phys. Scripta 91 035301 (2016)
  47. Darwin C G "The wave equations of the electron" Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 118 (780) 654 (1928)
  48. Gordon W "Die Energieniveaus des Wasserstoffatoms nach der Diracschen Quantentheorie des Elektrons" Z. Physik 48 (1) 11 (1928)
  49. Fok V A Nachala Kvantovoi Mekhaniki (M.: Nauka, Gl. red. fiz.-mat. lit., 1976); Per. na angl. yaz., Fock V A Fundamentals Of Quantum Mechanics (Moscow: Mir Publ., 1978)
  50. Granovskii Ya I "Formula Zommerfel’da i teoriya Diraka" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 174 577 (2004); Granovskii Ya I "Sommerfeld formula and Dirac’s theory" Phys. Usp. 47 523 (2004)
  51. Petrov S V "Oshibalsya li Zommerfel’d? (K istorii poyavleniya spina v relyativistskikh volnovykh uravneniyakh)" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 190 777 (2020); Petrov S V "Was Sommerfeld wrong? (To the history of the appearance of spin in relativistic wave equations)" Phys. Usp. 63 721 (2020)
  52. Darrigol O "A few reasons why Louis de Broglie discovered matter waves and yet did not discover Schrödinger’s equation" Erwin Schrödinger - 50 Years After (EMS ESI Lectures in Mathematics and Physics) Vol. 9 (Eds W L Reiter, J Yngvason) (Zürich: European Mathematical Society Publ. House, 2013) p. 165
  53. Weyl H The Theory Of Groups And Quantum Mechanics (New York: Dover Publications, 1950); Per. na russk. yaz., Veil’ G Teoriya Grupp i Kvantovaya Mekhanika (Ser. Biblioteka Teoreticheskoi Fiziki) (M.: Nauka, Gl. red. fiz.-mat. lit., 1986)
  54. Schrödinger Ann. Physik 79 (8) 734 (1926); Per. na angl yaz., Schrödinger "On the relation between the quantum mechanics of Heisenberg, Born, and Jordan, and that of Schrödinger" Collected Papers On Wave Mechanics (New York: AMS Chelsea Publ., 2010) p. 45-61; Per. na russk yaz., Shredinger E "Ob otnoshenii kvantovoi mekhaniki Geizenberga-Borna-Iordana k moei" Izbrannye Trudy Po Kvantovoi Mekhanike. Osnovopolagayushchie Raboty Po Volnovoi Mekhanike 1926-1927 Gg. (M.: Nauka, 1976) p. 56-74
  55. Blokhintsev D I Osnovy Kvantovoi Mekhaniki 5-e izd. (M.: Nauka, 1976); Per. na angl. yaz., Blokhintsev D I Quantum Mechanics (Dordrecht: Springer, 1964)
  56. Langer R E "On the connection formulas and the solutions of the wave equation" Phys. Rev. 51 669 (1937)
  57. Schrödinger E Naturwissenschaften 14 (28) 664 (1926); Per. na angl. yaz., Schrödinger E "The continuous transition from micro- to macro- mechanics" Collected Papers On Wave Mechanics (New York: AMS Chelsea Publ., 2010) p. 41-44; Per. na russk. yaz., Shredinger E "Nepreryvnyi perekhod ot mikro- k makromekhanike" Izbrannye Trudy Po Kvantovoi Mekhanike. Osnovopolagayushchie Raboty Po Volnovoi Mekhanike 1926-1927 Gg. (M.: Nauka, 1976) p. 51-55
  58. Kox A J "The debate between Hendrik A. Lorentz and Schrödinger on wave mechanics" Erwin Schrödinger - 50 Years After (EMS ESI Lectures in Mathematics and Physics) Vol. 9 (Eds W L Reiter, J Yngvason) (Zürich: European Mathematical Society Publ. House, 2013) p. 153
  59. Kryuchkov S I, Suslov S K, Vega-Guzmán J M "The minimum-uncertainty squeezed states for atoms and photons in a cavity" J. Phys. B 46 104007 (2013)
  60. Schrödinger E Ann. Physik 81 109 (1926); Per. na angl. yaz., Schrödinger E "Quantisation as a problem of proper values (Pt. IV)" Collected Papers On Wave Mechanics (New York: AMS Chelsea Publ., 2010) p. 102-123; Per. na russk. yaz., Shredinger E "Kvantovanie kak zadacha o sobstvennykh znacheniyakh. Chetvertoe soobshchenie" Izbrannye Trudy Po Kvantovoi Mekhanike. Osnovopolagayushchie Raboty Po Volnovoi Mekhanike 1926-1927 Gg. (M.: Nauka, 1976) p. 116-138
  61. Dyson F "Birds and Frogs" Notices AMS 56 (2) 212 (2009)
  62. Daison F "Ptitsy i lyagushki v matematike i fizike" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 180 859 (2010); Dyson F "Birds and frogs in mathematics and physics" Phys. Usp. 53 825 (2010)
  63. Schrödinger E Collected Papers On Wave Mechanics (New York: AMS Chelsea Publ., 2010); Per. na russk. yaz., Shredinger E Izbrannye Trudy Po Kvantovoi Mekhanike. Osnovopolagayushchie Raboty Po Volnovoi Mekhanike 1926 - 1927 Gg. (M.: Nauka, 1976)
  64. Fabelinskii I L "Kombinatsionnomu rasseyaniyu sveta - 70 let" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 168 1341 (1998); Fabelinskii I L "Seventy years of combination (Raman) scattering" Phys. Usp. 41 1229 (1998)
  65. Fabelinskii I L "Otkrytie kombinatsionnogo rasseyaniya sveta v Rossii i Indii" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 173 1137 (2003); Fabelinskii I L "The discovery of combination scattering of light in Russia and India" Phys. Usp. 46 1105 (2003)
  66. Ginzburg V L "Pochemu sovetskie uchenye ne vsegda poluchali zasluzhennye imi Nobelevskie premii?" Vestnik RAN 68 51 (1998); Ginzburg V L "Why Soviet scientists did not always get the Nobel Prizes they deserved" Ginzburg V L. About Science, Myself And Others (Boca Raton, Fl.: CRC Press, Taylor and Francis Group, 2005) p. 396
  67. Blokh A M Sovetskii Soyuz v Inter’ere Nobelevskikh Premii. Fakty. Dokumenty. Razmyshleniya. Kommentarii 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. (M.: Fizmatlit, 2005); Per. na angl. yaz., Blokh A M Soviet Union In The Context Of The Nobel Prize (Singapore: World Scientific, 2021)
  68. Heisenberg W Die Physikalischen Prinzipien Der Quantheorie (Leipzig: S. Hirzel, 1930); Per. na angl. yaz., Heisenberg W The Physical Principals Of The Quantum Theory (New York: Dover Publ., 1949); Per. na russk. yaz. s nem. A.N. Arsen’evoi (Pod red. D D Ivanenko), Geizenberg V Fizicheskie Printsipy Kvantovoi Teorii (M. - L.: GTTI, 1932)
  69. Dirac P A M The Principles Of Quantum Mechanics 4th ed. (Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press, 1958); Per. na russk. yaz., Dirak P A M Printsipy Kvantovoi Mekhanikis 3-e izd. (M.: Nauka, 1979)
  70. Hoffmann D Erwin Schrödinger (Biographien hervorragender Naturwissenschaftler Techniken und Mediziner) Vol. 66 (Leibzig: BSB B.G. Teubner Verlagssesellschaft, 1984); Per. na russk. yaz., Khoffman D Ervin Shredinger (M.: Mir, 1980)
© 1918–2024 Uspekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk
Email: ufn@ufn.ru Editorial office contacts About the journal Terms and conditions