Issues

 / 

1992

 / 

July

  

Methodological notes


Is probability a ’normal’ physical quantity?

,  a
a Space Research Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Profsoyuznaya str. 84/32, Moscow, 117997, Russian Federation

The informal aspects, arising in the interpretation of physical experiments, of the theory of probability and mathematical statistics are discussed. The conditions that verifying experiments must satisfy are presented and the role of heuristic (extralogical) assertions is analyzed using the example of mathematical expectation. The principal hypotheses implicit in experiments are enumerated: the principle of reproducibility (``the past will be repeated in the future''); the principle of reasonable sufficiency; and, the statistical principle (``better to predict something rather than nothing''). Considerable attention is devoted to Fisher and multisample confidence intervals. It is noted that Fisher confidence intervals are inconsistent. The arguments for introducing contrivances into practical calculations of probabilities are enumerated: incompleteness of any system of hypotheses; subjective estimates of probabilities; adjoining of statistical ensembles; nonstationariness and instability; rare phenomena; and, the use of classical probabilities and the law of large numbers. It is concluded that the relative frequency of appearance (empirical probability) is a ``normal'' physical quantity in the sense that it admits physical measurement. Its ``abnormality'' is manifested in the fact that it is burdened, more than other physical quantities, with conventions and hypotheses which must be specially checked (verified).

Fulltext pdf (1000 KB)
Fulltext is also available at DOI: 10.1070/PU1992v035n07ABEH002250
PACS: 02.50.Cw, 06.20.Dk, 05.20.Gg, 02.70.Rr (all)
DOI: 10.1070/PU1992v035n07ABEH002250
URL: https://ufn.ru/en/articles/1992/7/d/
Citation: Alimov Yu I, Kravtsov Yu A "Is probability a 'normal' physical quantity?" Sov. Phys. Usp. 35 (7) 606–622 (1992)
BibTexBibNote ® (generic)BibNote ® (RIS)MedlineRefWorks

Оригинал: Алимов Ю И, Кравцов Ю А «Является ли вероятность „нормальной“ физической величиной?» УФН 162 (7) 149–182 (1992); DOI: 10.3367/UFNr.0162.199207d.0149

References (38) ↓ Cited by (12) Similar articles (15)

  1. Vigner E. "Nepostizhimaya effektivnost’ matematiki v estestvennykh naukakh" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 94 535 (1968)
  2. Krylov A.N. Moi Vospominaniya (L.: Sudostroenie, 1979)
  3. Feinberg E.L. "Intellektual’naya revolyutsiya na putyakh edineniya "dvukh kul’tur"" Vopr. Filosofii (8) 33 (1986)
  4. Dushin E M (Red.) Osnovy Metrologii i Elektricheskie Izmereniya (L.: Energoatomizdat, 1987)
  5. Osnovopolagayushchie Standarty v Oblasti Metrologicheskogo Obespecheniya (M.: Goskomstandart, 1983)
  6. Kendall M., St’yuart A. Teoriya Raspredelenii (M.: Nauka, 1966)
  7. Kendall M., St’yuart A. Statisticheskie Vyvody i Svyazi (M.: Nauka, 1973)
  8. Kendall M., St’yuart A. Mnogomernyi Statisticheskii Analiz i Vremennye Ryady (M.: Nauka, 1976)
  9. Aivazyan S.A., Enyukov I.S., Meshalkin L.D. Prikladnaya Statistika: Osnovy Modelirovaniya i Pervichnaya Obrabotka Dannykh (M.: Finansy i statistika., 1983)
  10. Aivazyan S.A, Enyukov I.S., Meshalkin L.D. Prikladnaya Statistika: Issledovanie Zavisimostei (M.: Finansy i statistika, 1985)
  11. Aivazyan S.A., Enyukov I.S., Meshalkin L.D Prikladnaya Statistika: Klassifikatsiya i Snizhenie Razmernosti (M.: Finansy i statistika, 1989)
  12. Alimov Yu.I. Al’ternativa Metodu Matematicheskoi Statistiki (M.: Znanie, 1980)
  13. Alimov Yu.I. "Utilitarnaya logika postroeniya teorii veroyatnostei. № 24" Semiotika i Informatika (M.: VINITI, 1985) p. 58
  14. Alimov Yu.I. "Otsenka fisherovskoi teorii otsenivaniya s pozitsii metrologii" Statisticheskaya Obrabotka Eksperimental’nykh Dannykh (Novosibirsk: Novocib. elektrotekhn. in-t svyazi, 1986) p. 15
  15. Alimov Yu.I. Izmerenie Momentov Sistemy Sluchainykh Velichin (Sverdlovsk: Izd-vo UPI, 1984)
  16. Alimov Yu.I. Izmerenie Spektrov i Statisticheskikh Veroyatnostei (Sverdlovsk: Izd-vo UPI, 1986)
  17. Alimov Yu.I. Prognozirovanie Raspredelenii Veroyatnostei (Sverdlovsk: Izd-vo UPI, 1986)
  18. Alimov Yu.I,, Shaevich A.B. "Metodologicheskie osobennosti otsenivaniya rezul’tatov kolichestvennogo khimicheskogo analiza" Zh. Analit. Khimii 44 1983 (1988)
  19. Uittl N. Veroyatnost’ (M.: Nauka, 1982)
  20. Miees R., fon Veroyatnost’ i Statistika (M.; L.: Gosizdat, 1930)
  21. Tutubalin V.N. Teoriya Veroyatnostei (M.: Izd-vo Mosk. un-ta, 1972)
  22. Kolmogorov A.N. Osnovy Teorii Veroyatnostei (M.: Nauka, 1974)
  23. Alimov Yu.I "O problemakh prilozheniya teorii veroyatnostei, rassmotrennykh v rabotakh V.N. Tutubalina" Avtomatika (1) 71 (1978)
  24. Alimov Yu.I. "Eshche raz o realizme i fantastike v prilozheniyakh teorii veroyatnostei" Avtomatika (4) 83 (1979)
  25. Yaglom A.M. Korrelyatsionnaya Teoriya Statsionarnykh Sluchainykh Funktsii (L.: Gidrometeoizdat, 1981)
  26. El’yasberg P.E. Izmeritel’naya Informatsiya: Skol’ko Ee Nuzhno? Kak Obrabatyvat’? (M.; Nauka, 1983)
  27. Tutubalin. V.N. Teoriya Veroyatnostei v Estestvoznanii (M.: Znanie, 1972)
  28. Viner H. Tvorets i Robot (M.: Progress, 1966)
  29. Smirnov N.V., Dunin,Barkovskii I.V. Kurs Teorii Veroyatnostei i Matematicheskoi Statistiki (M.: Nauka, 1965)
  30. Zaidel’ A.N. Pogreshnosti Izmerenii Fizicheskikh Velichin (L.: Nauka, 1985)
  31. Grekova I. "Metodologicheskie osobennosti prikladnoi matematiki na sovremennom etape ee razvitiya" Vopr. Filosofii (6) 104 (1976)
  32. Kapitsa P.L Teoriya, Praktika, Eksperiment (M.: Nauka, 1984)
  33. Keller J B "The probability of heads" Am. Math. Monthly 93 191 (1986)
  34. Kolmogorov A N Sankhya Indian J. Statist. A 25 369 (1963); Kolmogorov A.N. "Tri podkhoda k opredeleniyu ponyatiya "kolichestvo informatsii"" Probl. Peredachi Informatsii 1 3 (1965); to zhe, Kolmogorov A.N. Teoriya Informatsii i Teoriya Algoritmov (M.: Nauka, 1987) p. 204, 215, obe stat’i
  35. Martin-Löf P "The definition of random sequences" Inf. Control 9 602 (1966)
  36. Kravtsov Yu.A. "Sluchainost’, determinirovannost’, nredskazuemost’" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 158 92 (1989); Kravtsov Yu A Sov. Phys. Usp. 32 434 (1989)
  37. Kravtsov Yu.A "Sluchainost’ i predskazuemost’ dinamicheskogo khaosa" Nelineinye Volny. T. 2 Dinamika i Evolyutsiya. (M.: Nauka, 1981) p. 81
  38. Bernulli Ya. O Zakone Bol’shikh Chisel (M.: Nauki, 1986), Ch. 4

© 1918–2024 Uspekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk
Email: ufn@ufn.ru Editorial office contacts About the journal Terms and conditions