Complementarity, physics, and biology

The views of Niels Bohr on complementarity are examined, both in physics and in other fields. N. Bohr's opinions on the relationship between physics and biology are discussed in detail. It is shown that, over a number of years, Bohr viewed as complementary the study of organisms as atomic-molecular and as integral systems. Subsequently, owing to the development of molecular biology, Bohr rejected the idea of the complementarity in principle of the stated two types of studies. The current status of the physical theory of biological phenomena is examined, and the role of synergetics in this field is noted. The so-called antireductionism is criticized. It is shown that the views of contemporary eminent theoretical biologists reveal them to be unfamiliar with physics. The very important role of physics in the further development of biology and its practical applications is emphasized.

PACS: 01.65.+g, 87.15.−v (all)
DOI: 10.1070/PU1988v031n02ABEH005698
URL: https://ufn.ru/en/articles/1988/2/c/
Citation: Vol’kenshtein M V "Complementarity, physics, and biology" Sov. Phys. Usp. 31 140–150 (1988)

BibTexBibNote ® (generic)BibNote ® (RIS)MedlineRefWorks

Оригинал: Волькенштейн М В «Дополнительность, физика и биология» УФН 154 279–297 (1988); DOI: 10.3367/UFNr.0154.198802e.0279

N. Bohr is author of Physics-Uspekhi

References (48) ↓ Cited by (5) Similar articles (20)

N. H. D. Bohr Collected Scientific Works (Russian Transl. Vol. Vol. 2 (Nauka, M., 1971) p. 519; Engl. original in Ref. 16 p. 94
N. H. D. Bohr Ibid. 393
N. H. D. Bohr Ibid. 397
N. H. D. Bohr Ibid. 287
N. H. D. Bohr Ibid. 399
L. I. Mandel’shtam Complete Collected Works (in Russian) Vol. Vol. 5 (Izd-vo AN SSSR, M., 1950) p. 347
N. Bohr see Ref. 1 p. 398
L. I. Mandel’shtam see Ref. 6 p. 54
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Structure And Physical Properties Of Molecules (in Russian) (Izd-vo-AN SSSR, L., 1955)
N. Bohr see Ref. 1 p. 481; N. Bohr Engl. Original 67, in Ref. 16
H. Wölfflin Principles Of Art History, The Problem Of The Development Of Style In Later Art (Henry Holt and Co., N. Y., 1932); Russ. transl., H. Wölfflin Principles Of Art History, The Problem Of The Development Of Style In Later Art (Academia, M., L., 1930)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Znanie-sila (No. 2) 81 (1987)
L. M. Lotman Realism Of The Russian Literature Of The 1860s (in Russian) (Nauka, L., 1974) p. 101–103
P. V. Simonov The Emotional Brain (in Russian) (Nauka, M., 1981)
P. V. Simonov The Motivated Brain (in Russian) (Nauka, M., 1987)
N. H. D. Bohr Atomic Physics And Human Knowledge (Wiley, N. Y., 1958); Russ. Transl., N. H. D. Bohr Atomic Physics And Human Knowledge (IL, M., 1961)
L. S. Berg Studies On The Theory Of Evolution (in Russian) (Nauka, L., 1977) p. 113
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Molek, Biol. 21 630 (1987), [Mol. Biol. (Moscow)]
W. Heitler Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientists ed., Schilpp, Tudor (New York, 1951) p. 196, 197
J. W. von Goethe Faust, Part I (conversation of Mephistopheles with the student, lines (cf. footnote 2)., 1936–1941)
E. P. Wigner Symmetries And Reflections: Scientific Essays (Indiana University Press, Bloomington and London, 1967); Russ. Transl., E. P. Wigner Symmetries And Reflections: Scientific Essays (Mir, M., 1980) p. 176
W. Elsasser The Physical Foundation Of Biology (Pergamon Press, London, 1958)
E. Mayr The Growth Of Biological Thought: Diversity, Evolution And Inheritance (The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1982)
E. Schrödinger What Is Life? (Macmillan, N. Y., 1946); Russ. Transl., E. Schrödinger What Is Life? (IL, M., 1947); E. Schrödinger What Is Life? (Atomizdat, M.)., 1972)
N. Bohr Speech At International Congress On Pharmaceutical Science (Copenhagen, Aug. 19, 1960); N. Bohr Russ. Transl., Usp. Fiz. Nauk 76 21 (1962)
N. Bohr Naturwissenschaften 50 725, (963)
V. L. Ginzburg Niels Bohr: Life And Creative Work ed. B. G. Kuznetsov (in Russian), Nauka, M., 1967) p. 26
D. S. Danin Niels Bohr (in Russian) (Molodaya Gvardiya, M., 1978)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n General Physics (Academic Press, N. Y., 1983); Russ. original, M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n General Physics (Nauka, M., 1978)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Biophysics (Mir, M., 1983); Russ. oiginal, M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Biophysics (Nauka, M., 1981), later ed. Nauka, 1988
Philosophical Dictionary (in Russian) (Politizdat, M., 1981) p. 315
Philosophical Dictionary (in Russian) (Politizdat, M., 1987) p. 408
A. M. Prokhorov Physics, Bol’shaya Sovetskaya Éntsiklopediya, 3rd Ed. Vol. 27 337 (1977), (in Russian)
M. V. Vol’kensht&ibreve;n Physical Theory (in Russian) (Nauka, M., 1980) p. 53
E. S. Bauer Theoretical Biology (Russ. transl., VIÉM, L., 1935)
G. Simpson This View Of Life (Harcourt, Brace, World, New York, 1964)
I. Prigogine From Being To Becoming (Freeman, S. F., 1980); Russ. Transl., I. Prigogine From Being To Becoming (Nauka, M., 1985)
I. Prigogine and I. Stengers Order Out Of Chaos (Bantam Books, N.Y., 1984); Russ. Transl., I. Prigogine and I. Stengers Order Out Of Chaos (Progress, M., 1986)
H. Haken Synergetics Revised ed. (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, New York, 1983); Russ. Transl., H. Haken Synergetics (Mir, M., 1985)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Physics And Biology (in Russian) (Nauka, M., 1980)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Entropy And Information (in Russian) (Nauka, M., 1986)
W. Ebeling and R. Feistel Physik Der Selbstorganisation Und Evolution (Akademie-Verlag, Berlin, 1986) p. 1982
B. N. Belintsev and M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 235 205 (1977); B. N. Belintsev and M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Dokl. Biol. Sci. 235 261 (1971)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Usp. Fiz. Nauk 143 429 (1984); M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Sov. Phys. Usp. 27 515 (1984)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Biol. (No. 3) 325 (1986)
M. V. Vol’kenshte&ibreve;n Vestn. Akad. Nauk SSSR. (No. 10) 99 (1986)
B. N. Belintsev Usp. Fiz. Nauk 141 55 (1983); B. N. Belintsev Sov. Phys. Usp. 26 775 (1983)
M. Perutz Nature 326 555 (1987)