Gravitation, photons, clocks

L.B. Okun^a, K.G. Selivanov^a, V.L. Telegdi^b
^aRussian Federation State Scientific Center ‘A.I. Alikhanov Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics’, ul. Bolshaya Cheremushkinskaya 25, Moscow, 117259, Russian Federation
^bEP Division, Geneva 23, CERN, Geneva, CH-1211, Switzerland

This paper is concerned with the classical phenomenon of gravitational red shift, the decrease in the measured frequency of a photon moving away from a gravitating body (e.g., the Earth). Of the two current interpretations, one is that at higher altitudes the frequency-measuring clocks (atoms or atomic nuclei) run faster, i.e. their characteristic frequencies are higher, while the photon frequency in a static gravitational field is independent of the altitude and so the photon only reddens relative to the clocks. The other approach is that the photon reddens because it loses the energy when overcoming the attraction of the gravitational field. This view, which is especially widespread in popular science literature, ascribes such notions as a ’gravitational mass’ and ’potential energy’ to the photon. Unfortunately, also scientific papers and serious books on the general theory of relativity often employ the second interpretation as a ’graphic’ illustration of mathematically immaculate results. We show here that this approach is misleading and only serves to create confusion in a simple subject.

PACS: 01.40.−d, 01.55.+b, 04.20.−q (all)
DOI: 10.1070/PU1999v042n10ABEH000597
URL: https://ufn.ru/en/articles/1999/10/d/
Web of Science

000083688700004
Citation: Okun L B, Selivanov K G, Telegdi V L "Gravitation, photons, clocks" Phys. Usp. 42 1045–1050 (1999)

BibTexBibNote ® (generic)BibNote ® (RIS)MedlineRefWorks

Оригинал: Окунь Л Б, Селиванов К Г, Телегди В «Гравитация, фотоны, часы» УФН 169 1141–1147 (1999); DOI: 10.3367/UFNr.0169.199910d.1141

References (59) Cited by (20) Similar articles (20) ↓

L.B. Okun’ “The concept of mass (mass, energy, relativity)” 32 629–638 (1989)
L.A. Rivlin “Photons in a waveguide (some thought experiments)” 40 291–303 (1997)
A.A. Logunov “The theory of the classical gravitational field” 38 179–193 (1995)
A.A. Logunov, M.A. Mestvirishvili, Yu.V. Chugreev “On incorrect formulations of the equivalence principle” 39 73–79 (1996)
E.G. Bessonov “Another route to the Lorentz transformations” 59 475–479 (2016)
R.I. Khrapko “Gravitational mass of the photons” 58 1115–1117 (2015)
V.I. Ritus “Lagrange equations of motion of particles and photons in the Schwarzschild field” 58 1118–1123 (2015)
P.B. Ivanov “On relativistic motion of a pair of particles having opposite signs of masses” 55 1232–1238 (2012)
S.I. Chermyanin “Predictions of the general theory of relativity are free from ambiguity” 33 (5) 385–387 (1990)
I.D. Novikov “Antigravitation in the Universe” 61 692–696 (2018)
A.A. Shatskii, I.D. Novikov, N.S. Kardashev “A dynamic model of the wormhole and the Multiverse model” 51 457–464 (2008)
G.S. Golitsyn “Demonstrativeness of using energy rather than mass as the unit of measure for a number of problems in physics, mechanics, and geophysics” 51 723–725 (2008)
M.O. Katanaev “Killing vector fields and a homogeneous isotropic universe” 59 689–700 (2016)
V.V. Popkov, E.V. Shipitsyn “Golden section in the Carnot cycle” 43 1155–1157 (2000)
V.L. Ginzburg, V.P. Frolov “Vacuum in a homogeneous gravitational field and excitation of a uniformly accelerated detector” 30 1073–1095 (1987)
V.B. Morozov “On the question of the electromagnetic momentum of a charged body” 54 371–374 (2011)
Ya.B. Zel’dovich, L.P. Grishchuk “Gravitation, the general theory of relativity, and alternative theories” 29 780–787 (1986)
V.L. Ginzburg, Yu.N. Eroshenko “Comments on the paper by A A Logunov et al.” 39 81–82 (1996)
V.L. Ginzburg, Yu.N. Eroshenko “Once again about the equivalence principle” 38 195–201 (1995)
L.I. Antonov “Macroscopic representation of the magnetization vector field in a magnetic substance” 46 1203–1207 (2003)

The list is formed automatically.