RSS feeds
ÐóññêèéEnglish
Issue 12, 2024
Volume year page
Issues Authors PACS Subscription For authors

Issues

 / 

1999

 / 

October

←  →

Methodological notes


Gravitation, photons, clocks

 a,  a,  b
a Russian Federation State Scientific Center ‘A.I. Alikhanov Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics’, ul. Bolshaya Cheremushkinskaya 25, Moscow, 117259, Russian Federation
b EP Division, Geneva 23, CERN, Geneva, CH-1211, Switzerland

This paper is concerned with the classical phenomenon of gravitational red shift, the decrease in the measured frequency of a photon moving away from a gravitating body (e.g., the Earth). Of the two current interpretations, one is that at higher altitudes the frequency-measuring clocks (atoms or atomic nuclei) run faster, i.e. their characteristic frequencies are higher, while the photon frequency in a static gravitational field is independent of the altitude and so the photon only reddens relative to the clocks. The other approach is that the photon reddens because it loses the energy when overcoming the attraction of the gravitational field. This view, which is especially widespread in popular science literature, ascribes such notions as a ’gravitational mass’ and ’potential energy’ to the photon. Unfortunately, also scientific papers and serious books on the general theory of relativity often employ the second interpretation as a ’graphic’ illustration of mathematically immaculate results. We show here that this approach is misleading and only serves to create confusion in a simple subject.

Fulltext pdf (214 KB)
Fulltext is also available at DOI: 10.1070/PU1999v042n10ABEH000597
PACS: 01.40.−d, 01.55.+b, 04.20.−q (all)
DOI: 10.1070/PU1999v042n10ABEH000597
URL: https://ufn.ru/en/articles/1999/10/d/
000083688700004
Citation: Okun L B, Selivanov K G, Telegdi V L "Gravitation, photons, clocks" Phys. Usp. 42 1045–1050 (1999)
BibTexBibNote ® (generic)BibNote ® (RIS)MedlineRefWorks

Îðèãèíàë: Îêóíü Ë Á, Ñåëèâàíîâ Ê Ã, Òåëåãäè Â «Ãðàâèòàöèÿ, ôîòîíû, ÷àñû» ÓÔÍ 169 1141–1147 (1999); DOI: 10.3367/UFNr.0169.199910d.1141

References (59) ↓ Cited by (20) Similar articles (20)

  1. Einstein A Jahrb. Radioaktivität Elektronik 4 411 (1907) [Translated into Russian in Sobranie Nauchnykh Trudov Vol. 1 (Moscow: Nauka, 1965) p.110]
  2. Einstein A Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 35 898 (1911) [Translated into Russian in Sobranie Nauchnykh Trudov Vol. 1 (Moscow: Nauka, 1965) p. 167]
  3. Einstein A Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 49 769 (1916) § 22 [Translated into Russian in Sobranie Nauchnykh Trudov Vol. 1 (Moscow: Nauka, 1965) p. 502]
  4. Einstein A Über die Specielle und Allgemeine Relativitäts Theorie (Gemeinverständlich, Braunschweig: Vieveg-Verlag, 1920) [Translated into English as Relativity: The Special and General Theory (New York: Crown Trade Paperbacks, 1961) p. 130] [Translated into Russian in Sobranie Nauchnykh Trudov Vol. 1 (Moscow: Nauka, 1965) p. 597]
  5. Einstein A The Meaning of Relativity (New York: Princeton University Press, 1921) Eqn (106)] [Translated into Russian in Sobranie Nauchnykh Trudov Vol. 2 (Moscow: Nauka, 1965) p. 5]
  6. Pais A "Subtle is the Lord ..." The Science and the Life of Albert Einstein (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982) Ch. 9 [Translated into Russian as Nauchnaya Deyatel’nost’ i Zhizn’ Al’berta Eînshteîna (Moscow: Nauka, 1989) Ch. 9, p. 5]
  7. Vizgin V P Relyativistskaya Teoriya Tyagoteniya (Istoki i Formirovanie) [Relativistic Theory of Gravitation (Sources and Formation)] (Moscow: Nauka, 1981)
  8. Corry L, Renn J, Stachel J Science 278 1270 (1997)
  9. Pound R, Rebka G Phys. Rev. Lett. 4 337 (1960); 4 275 (1960); 3 439 (1959)
  10. Pound R Usp. Fiz. Nauk 72 673 (1960) [Sov. Phys. Usp. 3 875 (1961)]
  11. Pound R, Snider J Phys. Rev. B 140 788 (1965); Phys. Lett. 13 539 (1964)
  12. Vessot R, Levine M Gen. Rel. Grav. 10 181 (1979)
  13. Haefele J, Keating R Science 117 166, 168 (1972)
  14. Alley C et al., in Experimental Gravitation: Proc. of the Conf. at Pavia (September 1976, Ed. B Bertotti, New York: Academic Press, 1977)
  15. Konopleva N P Usp. Fiz. Nauk 123 537 (1977) [Sov. Phys. Usp. 20 973 (1977)]
  16. Rudenko V N Usp. Fiz. Nauk 126 361 (1978) [Sov. Phys. Usp. 21 893 (1978)]
  17. Ginzburg V L O Teorii Otnositel’nosti (On the Theory of Relativity, Moscow: Nauka, 1979) p. 157
  18. Will C, in General Relativity (Eds S Hawking, W Israel, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979) Table 2 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Mir, 1983)]
  19. Will C Theory and Experiment in Gravitational Physics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981) Sect. 2.4 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Energoatomizdat, 1986) p. 34]
  20. Will C Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 1 13 (1992)
  21. Will C, Preprint WUGRAV-95-5; gr-qc/9504017 (1995)
  22. Shapiro I, in Astrofisica e Cosmologia, Gravitazione Quanti e Relatività (Firenze: Giunti Barbera, 1979) Sect. 3 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Mir, 1982) p. 218]
  23. Ashby N, Spilker J, in The Global Positioning System: Theory and Applications Vol. 1 (American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics Inc., 1995) Ch. 18
  24. Taylor J "Astronomical and space experiments to test relativity", in General Relativity and Gravitation (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987) p. 214
  25. Tonnelat M A "Les frequences en relative generale" ("Frequencies in general relativity") Ann. Inst. Henri Poincare 1 (1) 79 (1964) [Translated into Russian in Eînshteînovskiî Sbornik (Moscow: Nauka, 1967) p. 175]
  26. Pauli W Theory of Relativity (Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1967) Sect. 53 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Nauka, 1983) § 53]
  27. Möller C The Theory of Relativity (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1960) §§ 92, 93 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Atomizdat, 1975) § 8.12]
  28. Landau L, Lifshitz E Teoriya Polya (Field Theory, Moscow: Nauka, 1988) § 88 [Translated into English as The Classical Theory of Fields (Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1962) § 89]
  29. Weinberg S Gravitation and Cosmology (New York: Wiley, 1972) p. 79 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Mir, 1975) p. 95]
  30. Schneider P, Ehlers J, Falco E E Gravitational Lenses (Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1996) p. 93
  31. Straumann N General Relativity and Relativistic Astrophysics (Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1984) p. 96
  32. Dirac P A M General Theory of Relativity (New York: Wiley, 1975) [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Atomizdat, 1978)]
  33. Berkov A V, Kobzarev I Yu Teoriya Tyagoteniya Eînshteîna. Obshchie Printsipy i Eksperimental’nye Sledstviya (Einstein’s Theory of Gravitation, Moscow: Izd. MIFI, 1989) p. 88
  34. Ciufolini I, Wheeler J A Gravitation and Inertia (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995) p. 97
  35. Feynman R Lectures on Gravitation (Ed. B Hatfield, Redwood City, Calif.: Addison-Wesley Publ., 1995) Sect. 5.2
  36. Weyl H Raum, Zeit, Materie 5te Auflage (Berlin: Verlag von Julius Springer, 1923) S. 322; see also 7th edition published by J Ehlers (Springer-Verlag, 1988)
  37. Misner C, Thorne K, Wheeler J A Gravitation (San Francisco: Freeman and Company, 1973) §§ 7.2-7.5, 25.4, 38.5 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Mir, 1977)]
  38. Wald R W General Relativity (Chicago, London: University of Chicago Press, 1984) p. 137
  39. Stephani H General Relativity 2nd ed. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996) p. 117
  40. Kenyon I R General Relativity (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996) p. 15
  41. Born M Einstein’s Theory of Relativity (New York: Dover Publications, 1962) Ch. VII, § 11 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Mir, 1972) pp. 60, 342]
  42. Sciama D W The Physical Foundations of General Relativity (New York: Doubleday and Co., 1969) Ch. 5 [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Mir, 1971)]
  43. Zel’dovich Ya B, Novikov I D Teoriya Tyagoteniya i Evolyutsiya Zvezd (The Theory of Gravitation and Evolution of Stars, Moscow: Nauka, 1971) Ch. 3, § 4 [Translated into English as Relativistic Astrophysics Vol. 1 Stars and Relativity (Chicago, London: University of Chicago Press, 1971) p. 89]
  44. Braginskiî V B, Polnarev A G Udivitel’naya Gravitatsiya (ili Kak Izmeryayut Kriviznu Mira, Wonderful Gravitation and How to Measure the World Curvature, Moscow: Nauka, 1985) p. 29
  45. Syunyaev R A (Ed.) Fizika Kosmosa. Malen’kaya Entsiklopediya (Physics of Cosmos. Small Encyclopedia, Moscow: Bol’shaya Sovetskaya Entsiklopediya, 1986) p. 331
  46. The New Encyclopedia Britannica Vol. 20, 15th ed. (1994) p. 174
  47. Wheeler J A A Journey into Gravity and Spacetime (New York: Scientific American Library, 1990) pp. 48, 166
  48. Taylor E, Wheeler J A Spacetime Physics 3rd ed. (New York: Freeman and Co., 1992) pp. 258, 272 [Translated into Russian 2nd ed. (Moscow: Mir, 1971) pp. 200, 201, 295, 296]
  49. Layzer D Constructing the Universe Ch. 6 (New York: Scientific American Library, 1984) p. 210
  50. Bowler M G Gravitation and Relativity (New York: Pergamon Press, 1976) [Translated into Russian (Moscow: Mir, 1979)]
  51. Schwinger J Einstein’s Legacy (New York: Scientific American Library, 1986) p. 141
  52. Jain A K et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 58 1165 (1987)
  53. Anandan J Phys. Lett. A 105 280 (1984)
  54. Ginzburg V L Usp. Fiz. Nauk 59 11 (1956); 63 119 (1957)
  55. Ginzburg V L "Cosmic studies and the theory of relativity" Astronautica Acta 12 136 (1966) [Translated into Russian in Eînshteînovskiî Sbornik (Moscow: Nauka, 1967) p. 80]
  56. Brault J W Bull. Am. Phys. Soc. 8 28 (1963)
  57. Snider J L Phys. Rev. Lett. 28 853 (1972)
  58. Okun’ L B Usp. Fiz. Nauk 158 511 (1989) [Sov. Phys. Usp. 32 629 (1989)]
  59. Okun L B Phys. Today 42 (6) 31 (1989); 43 (5) 115 (1990)
© 1918–2024 Uspekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk
Email: ufn@ufn.ru Editorial office contacts About the journal Terms and conditions