RSS feeds
РусскийEnglish
Issue 12, 2024
Volume year page
Issues Authors PACS Subscription For authors

Issues

 / 

2022

 / 

December

←  →

Letters to the editors


What led to retraction of the article on room-temperature superconductivity in the journal Nature: a series of oversights or falsification?

† , , ‡ 
Lebedev Physical Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Leninsky prosp. 53, Moscow, 119991, Russian Federation

In 2020, the journal Nature published an article under the notorious title "Room-temperature superconductivity in a carbonaceous sulfur hydride" (Nature 586 373—377 (2020)) that caused, without exaggeration, an effect like an exploding bomb; after all, it was stated that one of the most important problems in modern physics (implementation of superconductivity at room temperature) has already been solved! In two years, the article has been cited over 500 times and read over 100,000 times. However, in the scientific community, the article led to a great deal of questions, skepticism, and severe criticism. Eventually, on September 26, 2022, Nature retracted this publication. We give here the main reasons for the retraction and our commentary on the significance of this act for the physics of high-temperature superconductivity in general and the superconductivity of hydrides in particular.

Fulltext pdf (470 KB)
To the readers pdf (115 KB)
Fulltext is also available at DOI: 10.3367/UFNe.2022.11.039265
Keywords: room-temperature superconductivity, high pressures, hydrides
PACS: 74.25.−q, 74.70.−b, 99.10.−x (all)
DOI: 10.3367/UFNe.2022.11.039265
URL: https://ufn.ru/en/articles/2022/12/i/
001112544300008
2-s2.0-85182903704
2022PhyU...65.1313S
Citation: Sadakov A V, Sobolevsky O A, Pudalov V M "What led to retraction of the article on room-temperature superconductivity in the journal Nature: a series of oversights or falsification?" Phys. Usp. 65 1313–1316 (2022)
BibTexBibNote ® (generic)BibNote ® (RIS)MedlineRefWorks

Received: 14th, October 2022, 10th, November 2022

Оригинал: Садаков А В, Соболевский О А, Пудалов В М «Что привело к изъятию статьи о комнатно-температурной сверхпроводимости из журнала "Nature": череда оплошностей или фальсификация?» УФН 192 1409–1412 (2022); DOI: 10.3367/UFNr.2022.11.039265

References (24) ↓ Cited by (4) Similar articles (1)

  1. Ginzburg V L "Superconductivity: the day before yesterday-yesterday-today-tomorrow" Phys. Usp. 43 573-583 (2000); Ginzburg V L "Sverkhprovodimost’: Pozavchera, vchera, segodnya, zavtra" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 170 619-630 (2000)
  2. Ginzburg V L "A few comments on superconductivity research" Phys. Usp. 48 173-176 (2005); Ginzburg V L "Neskol’ko zamechanii ob izuchenii sverkhprovodimosti" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 175 187-190 (2005)
  3. Ginzburg V L "On superconductivity and superfluidity (what I have and have not managed to do), as well as on the ’physical minimum’ at the beginning of the XXI century (December 8, 2003)" Phys. Usp. 47 1155-1170 (2004); Ginzburg V L "O sverkhprovodimosti i sverkhtekuchesti (chto mne udalos’ sdelat’, a chto ne udalos’), a takzhe o ’fizicheskom minimume’ na nachalo XXI veka" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 174 1240-1255 (2004)
  4. Ginzburg V L "Physical minimum’ — what problems of physics and astrophysics seem now to be especially important and interesting at the beginning of the XXI century?" Phys. Usp. 50 332 (2007); Ginzburg V L "Fizicheskii minimum’ — kakie problemy fiziki i astrofiziki predstavlyautsya osobenno vazhnymi i interesnymi v nachale XXI veka?" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 177 346 (2007)
  5. Snider E et al "RETRACTED ARTICLE: Room-temperature superconductivitya carbonaceous sulfur hydride" Nature 586 373-377 (2020)
  6. Snider E et al "Retraction Note: Room-temperature superconductivitya carbonaceous sulfur hydride" Nature 610 804 (2022)
  7. Drozdov A P et al "Conventional superconductivity at 203 kelvat high pressuresthe sulfur hydride system" Nature 525 73-76 (2015)
  8. Eremets M I, Drozdov A P "High-temperature conventional superconductivity" Phys. Usp. 59 1154-1160 (2016); Eremets M I, Drozdov A P "Vysokotemperaturnye obychnye sverkhprovodniki" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 186 1257-1263 (2016)
  9. Semenok D V et al "Superconductivity at 161 Kthorium hydride ThH10: Synthesis and properties" Mater. Today 33 36-44 (2020)
  10. Troyan I A et al "Anomalous high-temperature superconductivityYH6" Adv. Mater. 33 2006832 (2021)
  11. Drozdov A P et al "Superconductivity at 250 Klanthanum hydride under high pressures" Nature 569 528-531 (2019)
  12. Hirsch J E, Marsiglio F "Unusual width of the superconducting transitiona hydride" Nature 596 E9-E10 (2021); Dogan M, Cohen M L "Anomalous behavior in high-pressure carbonaceous sulfur hydride" Physica C 583 1353851 (2021)
  13. Talantsev E F, Crump W P, Storey J G, Tallon J L "London penetration depth and thermal fluctuationsthe sulfur hydride 203 K superconductor" Ann. Physik 529 1600390 (2017)
  14. Hirsch J E "TEMPORARY REMOVAL: On the ac magnetic susceptibility of a room temperature superconductor: anatomy of a probable scientific fraud" Physica C 1353964 (2021), Available online 26 September 2021, Withdrawn Article in Press
  15. Hirsch J E arXiv:2110.12854
  16. Hirsch J E, van der Marel D Matter. Radiat. Extrem. 7 048401 (2022)
  17. Wang T, Hirayama M, Nomoto T, Koretsune T, Arita R, Flores-Livas J A "Absence of conventional room-temperature superconductivity at high pressurecarbon-doped H3S" Phys. Rev. B 104 (6) 064510 (2021)
  18. Troyan I A, Semenok D V, Ivanova A G, Kvashnin A G, Zhou D, Sadakov A V, Sobolevskiy O A, Pudalov V M, Lyubutin I S, Oganov A R "High-temperature superconductivityhydrides" Phys. Usp. 65 748-761 (2022); Troyan I A, Semenok D V, Ivanova A G, Kvashnin A G, Zhou D, Sadakov A V, Sobolevskiy O A, Pudalov V M, Lyubutin I S, Oganov A R "Vysokotemperaturnaya sverkhprovodimost’ v gidridakh" Usp. Fiz. Nauk 192 799-813 (2022)
  19. Gubler M et al arXiv:2109.10019
  20. Tinkham M Introduction To Superconductivity (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1975); Translated into Russian, Tinkham M Vvedenie V Sverkhprovodimost’ (Moscow: Atomizdat, 1980); Tinkham M Introduction To Superconductivity 2nd ed. (New York: Dover Publ., 2004)
  21. Dias R P, Salamat A arXiv:2111.15017
  22. van der Marel D, Hirsch J E "Room-temperature superconductivity — or not? Comment on Nature 586, 373 (2020) by E. Snider et al." Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 37 2375001 (2023)
  23. Dias R P, Salamat A "Standard superconductivity in carbonaceous sulfur hydride" arXiv:2111.15017
  24. "Schön scandal". Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sch%C3%B6n_scandall
© 1918–2024 Uspekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk
Email: ufn@ufn.ru Editorial office contacts About the journal Terms and conditions